The following was translated from Lehre und Wehre, 63, pp. 468–469.
Christliche Dogmatik. By Dr. Franz Pieper. Second volume. Concordia Publishing House, St. Louis, Mo. 672 pages bound in linen with title on spine and cover. Price: $4.00.
This work, which thousands will welcome with pleasure, is already sufficiently characterized in Lehre und Wehre. Nevertheless, we do not wish to fail to give some remarks. Admittedly not every Lutheran can write a dogmatics, but only a Lutheran can write a truly Christian dogmatics. Why? Because only he does not stand merely according to the faith of his heart, but also according to his knowledge in the center of Christianity. Whoever does not take his position in the center, neither sees everything rightly nor rightly sees and judges that which he sees. In theology, this standpoint is to just actually sit in Scripture, see everything through Scripture, and judge according to Scripture. However, not everyone who operates with the words of Scripture and knows how to surround himself with a learned, exegetical atmosphere actually sits in Scripture, but only he who has taken his standpoint in the actual heart of Scripture. However, this heart of Christianity is nothing but the Scripture doctrine of the grace of God in Christ Jesus, according to which only faith justifies, regenerates, and brings salvation. And at the very heart of [mitten in] this doctrine of grace, Dr. Pieper’s dogmatics now takes its firm, all-encompassing, and dominating position. It is therefore entirely appropriate, and corresponds to the logic of the matter, that the second volume of this dogmatics, in which the Christian doctrine of grace is the central question, was published first. In the doctrines that are treated in this volume, all threads of theology come together and are gather up in a knot in the doctrine of justification and conversion. Here, a theologian reveals at every turn whether he actually grasps the entire situation; whether he has actually grasped not merely all manner of Christian doctrines and truths, but the Christian doctrine, the truth of the Gospel, to which everything else relates as antecedens and consequens, and is able to explain and defend it rightly in every direction. Thus, anyone can immediately convince himself through this second volume, which deals with the doctrine of grace, that he has before himself a dogmatics that is actually centered on Scripture. Scripture, the teaching of Scripture from its own innermost core [innersten Mittelpunkt] — that is just what Pieper’s dogmatics offers.
A peculiarity of the Missouri Synod is also this, that she truly remains in the theological standpoint, which she has taken from the beginning. Walther’s position is still the position of the Missouri Synod. What Walther, what Dr. Pieper himself now almost forty years later teaches constantly as a professor at the seminary in St. Louis, is adequately expressed in this dogmatics. Missouri has so far found no sufficient reason to depart from its position. And anyone who picks up this volume can convince himself that, even today, there is still no reason to do so. He takes us right into the heart of the struggles that Missouri has had to fight for more than seventy-five years now. For it is ultimately his doctrine of grace that caused the great rumors about Missouri in America. Also the Missourian struggle on the doctrine of church and office is based on nothing other than the doctrine of justification. Consequently, Romanism in the doctrine of church and office always boils down to a falsification of the Lutheran doctrine of “faith alone.” We gladly admit it: Walther, Missouri is essentially only the “repristination” of Luther and his doctrine of grace. And no attentive Lutheran will put down this volume of Pieper’s dogmatics without taking away the impression: Missouri’s struggle for the Lutheran truth — it was a great, glorious, holy, and victorious war! And the clarity, certainty, firmness, and decisiveness with which Dr. Pieper moves, both in the presentation of the Scripture teaching and in the refutation of the antitheses, instill confidence that here a master in Israel speaks, a reliable guide whom no one can follow in his arguments without at the same time arriving at his own certainty. Over the decades, many of the bizarre prejudices against Walther and his theology have fallen away. And whoever would like to shed the last vestiges of his distrust against Missouri and convince himself that, in Walther and the theologians and congregations that have rallied around him, Luther’s Lutheranism has indeed experienced an American resurrection, should read this second volume of Dr. Pieper’s dogmatics. F. B.



